Monday, 09 Dec 2024

Young men on being Republican in New York: ‘It caused all types of consternation among my friends’

Young men on being Republican in New York: ‘It caused all types of consternation among my friends’


Young men on being Republican in New York: ‘It caused all types of consternation among my friends’

In New York City, Republicans are something of a rarity. Only 10% of New Yorkers are Republicans, according to 2021 voter registration data, and the state is polling bright blue for Kamala Harris. But the Republican party has not called it quits.

"You live in a blue city, but it's going red very, very quickly," Donald Trump claimed at a Bronx rally in May. Step into the suburbs, and Republican candidates have enough momentum to turn multiple House elections - and ultimately, control of the House - into nail-biters.

It's an interesting time for the New York Young Republicans Club (NYYRC). The club brings together conservative New Yorkers 40 and under to socialize, campaign and discuss policy; recent events have included debate watch parties and a self-defense course in light of "illegal military-age male immigrants flooding our country, the threat of World War III, and New York's insistence on stripping our Second Amendment rights". It's using this momentum in New York to branch out to other Republican youth organizations around the country.

This year, the photographer Paola Chapdelaine spent time with four male members of NYYRC and one male member of the nearby Connecticut Young Republicans, who represent a nationwide trend of young men increasingly embracing the right. Here, they explain how they found their way to the Republican party as young men in a liberal city and what they think of political polarization in America.

When I was an undergrad, I saw a woman on the train with a button on her backpack that said "a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle". I remember completely disagreeing with that. This move towards dissolving the family, or saying that we don't need each other and we could just be these totally individualized, autonomous beings with no connection to family, with no connection to our history, I reject that idea. I think we're all connected to something greater. I guess that's what makes me a conservative.

Recently, I thought I had a great rapport with a date - lots of laughter, great chemistry. Then, the morning of the second date, she [texted]: "Hey, I did some thinking, and never mind. I would not like to go on a date with you." I immediately knew that she Googled me. I'm not a rightwing vigilante, but I write for conservative publications.

If I start immediately in a relationship by saying: "Hi, I'm Frank, I'm a conservative," then I'm setting myself up for failure. I say: "Hi, I'm Frank, I have a cat that I love. These are my hobbies. I play guitar." That's not to say you should be deceptive about your beliefs, but it is to say that you should be cognizant of the political polarization in this country. I think it was Muhammad Ali who said that he judges people based on how they treat waiters at restaurants. Similarly, how do you treat animals? I think squabbling over the tax code, or the right number of immigrants we should have per year, or how you feel about foreign policy ultimately mean nothing to me in a relationship. What I care about is how you treat me and how you treat others.

I sound like a hippy, but I also totally believe in this idea of community, and that community cannot be politically monolithic. It has to have Democrats in it, has to have liberals. The second we go to the "me versus them" or "us versus them" mentality, we're doomed.

Born, raised and currently living in Brooklyn, Filocomo is program manager at the conservative non-profit National Review Institute. He serves as policy chairman of NYYRC

It was 2008 and I was a political free agent. This was when everybody was like, "Obama, Obama, Obama." He was the hope and change guy. But he was saying stuff like: "These billionaires and millionaires have made too much on American people. It's time for them to spread the wealth" - like socialists. And I was like: "I can't vote for this guy."

That's when I leaned on biblical faith and started researching the political parties. Growing up in New York, most Black people are implicit Democrats or explicit Democrats. My friend Ben, who was a socialist, illustrated to me what it takes to be courageous and not fall into the trend, to express your opinion. I don't necessarily agree with socialism, I just felt like he was very courageous.

I felt like the Republican party was more in alignment with freedom, more in alignment with business, more in alignment with marriage, more in alignment with life in the womb. I was like, "OK, I could get down with that." It caused all types of consternation amongst my friends, my girlfriend at the time. People were having interventions. My dad kind of renounced me as a son. It was very, very tough.

In this election, I believe we should promote the interests of America first. A lot of people are hurting now economically. I don't see the benefit in sending money over to Ukraine, a bunch of foreign aid, a border that's open, when we have to take care of our citizens.

Somefun is philanthropy chairman of NYYRC. He was born and raised in Harlem and currently lives there. He is a life insurance agent

I got started with the College Republicans my sophomore year. There were four of us, so, like, something had to change. So we made it a very conversation-centric group. Our first topic was the Afghanistan pullout, because that was timely. Veganism was a recent [topic] we did, but the conversation was very good. We had a transgenderism and athletics meeting that was probably our most contentious.

The club is College Republicans, there's no hiding from that, and still, we've gotten a very dynamic group of people that are willing to have conversations. We have respect for ourselves. We have respect for the campus, but we don't take ourselves too seriously. It's something I see where other college Republican groups falter.

From the outside, I'm a raging conservative, but biodiversity concerns me [as a farmer]. Still, I don't share the same concerns [as environmental activists] with GMOs and stuff, because I see there's a need when you have a world of 8 billion people to feed. I try not to criticize farmers that are at a much larger scale than me by saying: "Just let there be more ladybugs and your crops will be fine."

Republicans are very much a party of clean air, clean water. When you want to talk about global warming and such, that's where you lose us. I'm much more appreciative of the climate change conversation if folks I'm talking to are willing to rank their issues. That's a hard thing to do, and maybe a very cold way of thinking. But what's the biggest issue, carbon in the atmosphere or plastic on the ground? Biodiversity? I think there's a lot of benefits to nuclear [power], but no one wants to be the guy that stakes a claim to nuclear out of concern that things go bad.

Carrier is the former president of College Republicans at University of Rochester and current statewide chairman of the Connecticut Young Republicans, as well as a political consultant and small scale farmer and beekeeper. He is from Enfield, Connecticut

So many younger people in New York are conservative, but they're scared to actually come out and say that they're conservative. [There's also] a quarter of the party, and it tends to be these younger, reactionary kids, who will regurgitate whatever certain conservative influencers say, rather than reading and thinking for themselves.

I was the only gay guy and the only pro-Bush guy in fourth grade. To me, conservatism is about actual individuality and autonomy and the understanding that the only real authority that we should appreciate and look towards is God, versus the government and elected officials. I mean, I fully believe in community. Most public schools, before the [federal government] took over and established the failing Department of Education, were run by communities. The more you involve the [federal government], the less control communities have, individuals have, and the worse off we are.

[In 2024], I think we need to stop funneling all this money to Israel and Ukraine and honestly, every other country that we're funneling money to. Actually, Israel is a little trickier than Ukraine. I do think it's a stabilizing country [in the Middle East], but still we're hemorrhaging money while our debt is going up. We're in an economically terrifying situation right now.

Wintrich lives in New York's East Village. He is a media strategist and PR consultant and serves as press chairman of NYYRC

One of the biggest problems I see with New York and other cities that lean liberal is that there's a degradation of property rights. There's potential for squatters. Tenants have the right to not pay and stay within the property. It's also landlords abusing their position by not following their legal responsibilities. When people don't pay rent or don't abide by their contracts, that's probably a gateway to people refusing to obey laws, refusing to follow established norms and conventions. It prevents people from living as moral people.

I support the party. I support Trump. Trump did the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. A couple months ago, I filed my tax return, and I saw I got a little extra money from that. He also [signed a bipartisan bill] funding HBCUs, which my mother, who's a college professor, was really grateful for. He met with Kanye to see what could be done to remedy the injustice of more Black people being in prison - reducing the incarceration problem. The First Step Act, allowing the formerly incarcerated to re-enter society, was bipartisan, and it was passed. But with the [current] political environment, it doesn't seem feasible that anyone is going to get much done.

[I'm also concerned about the] two recent assassination attempts on Trump. It seems like political violence is becoming more normalized in our society, which makes things much more unstable as things get close to election day.

Baryeh is a financial analyst. He lives in the Bronx and is a board member of the NYYRC Catholic caucus

you may also like

Flight passengers dive into myths and legends surrounding this busy airport
  • by foxnews
  • descember 09, 2016
Flight passengers dive into myths and legends surrounding this busy airport

The Denver International Airport in Colorado has caught the attention of many visitors for its unusual art, history and size, sparking travelers to discuss myths and legends.

read more